« This is for you, Dixon Ticonderoga. | Main | Babymouse: Queen of the World! and Babymouse: Our Hero -- Jennifer L. Holm & Matthew Holm »

24 January 2006

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

C.C.

I agree about Inexcusable, robbed. FYI, the Newbery link goes to the Caldecott page (not that I couldn't figure it out or anything, but thought ya might like to know).

Chrissy

God, I feel so out of touch.

Leila

Robbed. Also, I'm shocked that Sandpiper didn't get a mention.

Then again, maybe they're trying to avoid the Avi syndrome.

jess

I swore loudly when I read the Newbery list. Tee-ohed, to say the least.

C.C.

Oh yeah, except: Goodbye Window ruled, (now I'm going to have to go pull down Waffle and cry a lot, and then make a note to remember to buy Charlie Parker Played BeBob, Mysterious Thelonious, A Poke in the Eye and Yo! Yes? on Saturday). I haven't read any of the other Prinz honors/winners either. I'm sorry I CANNOT read Looking for Alaska, it's in my contract allowing me out of the state. Black Juice does look interesting though, and the Princess Academy is promising based on The Goose Girl. Very unusual treatment of the the "retold fairy tale genre". Contemplative. Philosophical. I liked it a lot.

Oh, and YAY! for Jacqueline Woodson, it's about time she get's a life time award for always writing good books about interesting things in a good way. There aren't enough awards out there for stuff like that.

Finally: I finally got my paws on Indigo's Star and loved it. Did you read the Horn Book article about her? Something to the effect that when she won some award (Smarties I'm sure) the introducer was like, "And finally, just some nice books about some funny people, with no issues." And the article writer was like, "Well, unless by "issues" you don't mean: adoption, bullying, romance, marriage, divorce, infidelity, glasses, and the handicapped. But I see "the introducers" point in that they don't seem like "issues" books." Yay Hilary McKay.

Leila

How much did you love Rose? She's so much like Phoebe, but different. Her ongoing mural killed me. I'll have to look up the Horn Book article -- the 'no issues' thing is a riot. But I get what the introduction meant, too -- they aren't angsty books at all. No moaning and groaning about the hardships they face and blah-di-blahblah. The books are about the people, not the issues. (Phew. It took me a long time to come to a very simple point. Sorry.)

Looking for Alaska has nothing to do with the state, from what I remember -- there's a character named Alaska, is all. I liked it, but I didn't love it. I would have been okay with it getting an Honor, but not so much the actual Award. Chris Lynch's book was WAY more deserving, I think.

The comments to this entry are closed.

GA

Blog powered by Typepad