« A Wrinkle in Time in 90 seconds. | Main | Turns out... »

17 January 2011

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8345169e469e20148c7b41233970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference I have a new column up...:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

tanita

Eh... at least the covers are very polished.

Carrie K

I started Vixen a month ago and just. can't. do. it.

Brandy

I got a copy of Vixen for review, too, and I completely agree with your take. Liked the cover and the book sounded promising, but ultimately, no way. (The one thing that struck me: in the '20s, would someone have known that a pregnancy was 13 weeks along? And/or would they have openly discussed it? I have a poor sense of history but those details seemed wrong to me.)

Himissjulie

My biggest annoyance was the lack of authentic voice, Vixen moreso than Bright Young Things. A 17 year old girl in 1923 would NOT use the word black to describe African Americans. From the research I've done, the terms in use would have been colored or negro (small n). If you're going to write historical fiction, I think you need to use the vocabulary of the time, especially when you're writing from the point of view of the characters. Ugh. That one point just drove me absolutely batty. Attempting to portray an interracial romance during the turbulent 20's could have been an amazing and gutsy novel; Larkin's portrayal, however, is lukewarm at best.

Julie

That last comment was mine, btw; I don't know where that weird typepad sign in came from. And I wanted to add--even though I sort of hated Vixen, I am also dying to know what happens next. Even though the characters were all utter non-entities.

Leila

Brandy: That seems wrong to me, too, but I don't have any facts to back me up, either! At that point, I'd given up on the idea of any sort of believability.

Julie: YES. I noticed that, too -- and that was in addition to the awfulness of the voice (internal and external) in general. When I said that she didn't take the easy way out with the interracial relationship, it was because I WAS SO POSITIVE that the author was going to kill his character off that I gave her points for NOT doing so. Which is a REALLY LOW BAR, but hey. It would have to be a pretty low bar to say much positive about it. That said, I'm glad I'm not the only one who wants to know what happens next.

April

I'm so glad to learn that someone else had a similar reaction to both of those books. I tried reading Vixen not too long after Bright Young Things, and I couldn't even finish it.

Maureen

Aw, man, I was kind of excited for Vixen. But bad dialogue is one of my top turn-offs. Poo.

The comments to this entry are closed.

GA

Blog powered by Typepad