« The WSJ is dead to me. | Main | My apologies. I've been in a bit of a reading slump for the last couple of days. »

28 July 2006

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Fuse #8

And people wonder why I don't review YA. Say what you will about six-year-olds, their insults are far more creative than that of 13-year-olds.

A lovely response, by the way. It's always fun to watch cretins get their due.

Chrissy

If that kid thinks you come off as an arrogant prick, what exactly does he think *he* comes off as?

He almost had me on the first sentence. I understand many first books of series fall flat as they introduce chracters, settings, basic plot lines. This phenomenon is a shame since it tends to casue many readers to not want to bother continuing with the rest of a series (not saying you should, or you had any intention of reviewing the *series*, just pointing out flat openers). But the minute the kid got insulting is when he loses all credibility. He could of just said why he liked the books and given you a reason to maybe check out some more of the.

On the other hand, Leila, I greatly appreciate your sometimes blunt, but never sugar coated reviews. You are the reason I read so much that I would never pick up on my own. And I don't always agree with you. I just read someting that I'm finding myself going "and why exactly should I like this?" (yes, I'm getting to my review of it). But that's me and that's you and we can co-exist just fine like that.

I'd never call you a prick. Sometimes a feak, but that's for completely different reasons.

Leila

I do kind of wonder about the e-mailer's age. Judging from the posts at the "We Hate Leila" forum, there's a decent range.

And Chrissy: Oh, goody. I always love reading your reviews, but I especially love reading them when you hate a book. Even if I loved it. (And thank you.)

Chrissy

Then hold onto your seat lady because I'm not real thrilled with the other book I'm reading. I thought it wasn't going to go where I expected it was and it turns out it is going there. But I'm not done with it yet, so it may go yammering off in a different direction that I will feel better about.

Leila

WHEE! (Also maybe a little bit scary, but mostly WHEE!)

The comments to this entry are closed.

GA

Blog powered by Typepad