So, in Envy (spoilers ahead if you haven't read the first two books):
Since Penelope blackmailed Henry into marrying her by threatening to reveal her knowledge about Henry and Diana getting horizontal, he's spent most of his waking hours trying to drink himself into oblivion and the marriage has not been consummated because he hates her and sleeps on the couch, a fact that is unknown to Diana because she has burned every single letter he's sent to her since the wedding and because Penelope has been sure that he Keeps Up Appearances in public. Elizabeth's very brief marriage to her True Love the stable boy Will Keller was lovely, but her period of mourning is difficult not only because hello, she's grieving, but also because the marriage was a secret and No One Can Know About It or The Family Will Be Ruined. Her grief has also been affecting her ability to keep food down. And Lina is continuing to claw her way to the top of the social ladder.
So, the whole crew of non-friends heads down to Florida for a vacation where trysts are had, Elizabeth suffers from motion sickness on the train, Teddy makes laser beam eyes of love at Elizabeth, Diana and Henry make laser beam eyes of love at each other and Penelope makes laser beam eyes of death at both of them, Diana keeps losing her shoes, there is sea-bathing, much liquor is tossed back, money is gambled, secrets are found out and Life-Changing Decisions Are Made.
This is another series that I can't help reading, even though there's no logical reason for me to continue. Not because of the writing, like that other *cohouseofnightugh* series I can't stop reading, though I do think that they could be edited down a tad*. It's that, minus the amazing twist at the end of the second book, I've never been really surprised by anything that's happened. And that, unless something way crazy happens in the next (and last) book, everything's so clearly going in a certain direction that it might as well all be wrapped up in my mind.
Yet, like Days, it's somehow still fascinating. Maybe because I do have some amount of affection for some of the the characters. And because even though they all started out like time-traveling clones of the Gossip Girl characters, they've become their own selves in my mind. Penelope Hayes is not longer the 1900 version of Blair Waldorf. Blair Waldorf is a beast, but I can't help liking her. Penelope Hayes, on the other hand, I could shove down three flights of stairs and smile while I watched her tumble. So there's that. And I'm curious to see which way things will go with Lina. Because on one hand, she's selfish and conniving and backstabby, with no real sense of honor or loyalty, so I'd like to see her go down. But on the other, if she does, then the only major characters from the lower class will have suffered bad ends. I'M ALL CONFLICTED.
______________________________________________________________
*Then again, if the books were thinner, HarperCollins wouldn't be able to wrap those pretty, pretty covers around them.
______________________________________________________________
Previously:
Ah yes, the old Her Grief Has Also Been Affecting Her Ability to Keep Food Down Syndrome, with a side of motion sickness. Can't imagine where THAT one's going in, say, seven or eight months . . .
Posted by: Gina | 06 April 2009 at 12:31 PM
Lol. I agree with it all. So now I want to know how do you think it's going to play out?
Posted by: Angie | 06 April 2009 at 01:37 PM
I can't help it either. Love 'em.
Posted by: Stacy | 06 April 2009 at 06:35 PM
irrelevant, but:
http://pan-dan.blogspot.com/2009/04/oh-farmer-and-cowman-should-be-friends.html
i didn't know where else to post this, and i KNOW you'll enjoy this.
-Colleen
Posted by: Colleen | 06 April 2009 at 08:17 PM
I haven't been able to bring myself to read this one, though I ate the first two up like candy -- until the second became a wallbanger for me.
Let's see: "I'll marry this evil bitch who I don't like at all because she's saying that if I don't she'll let everyone know I've been sleeping with my True Love and that will ruin my True Love. Never mind the fact that if I just up and marry my True Love, which we both want to do, her reputation will NOT be ruined, AND I've also been sleeping with the evil bitch, so I could very easily tell her I'll ruin HER reputation if she tries to ruin my True Love's."
Henry -- you're TSTL.
Posted by: Keeping it Anon | 07 April 2009 at 09:19 AM
Ah, but don't forget the "I'm Also Being Pressured By My Aspiring Mayor Father To Marry Money And It Would Look Exceedingly Bad For the Campaign If I Married My Pretendy-Dead-Fiancee's Genteely Poor Sister".
So there's that. But you're right that he could've turned it around on Penelope. Rats. I don't think our Henry is too bright. All of the drinking may have dulled his conniving skills.
If you liked the first two (minus Herny's TSTLness), I'd suggest that you go ahead and read the third. And just think: there's only one more planned, so there'll actually be an ending, rather than endless recycling of the same issues over and over and over again, a la (my beloved) Days!
Posted by: Leila | 07 April 2009 at 10:46 AM
Yeah, but the Dad was totally pressuring him to marry the Pretendy Dead Genteely Poor Original Fiancee and DIDN'T want him marrying nouveau riche and trashy Penelope. Wouldn't it have been even BETTER for Daddy's political career if he'd gone off with the Other Sister?
I just don't get what the scandal of that would have been. I can make up a newspaper headline for that right now: "Couple Bonds Over Death of Beloved Sister/Bride."
"I think Elizabeth would be happy, knowing we've found each other," said the new Mrs. Schoonmaker, who, in keeping with mourning for her sister, wore a fetching black suit rather than the traditional bridal white, "and that neither of us have to be alone anymore."
Posted by: Still keeping it anon | 07 April 2009 at 05:01 PM
This is a young adult novel, but effective enough for those of all ages who enjoy seeing the lives of other people in secret. Think of it like Gossip Girl for the game of historical fiction, and has a good sense of fun and drama involved. I am looking forward to the third installment of envy.
Posted by: גני אירועים | 28 March 2011 at 05:30 AM