Pish Posh -- Ellen Potter

Pish Posh begins:

If you walked into the Pish Posh restaurant on any given night, you would be sure to find a smallish eleven-year-old girl wearing large black sunglasses sitting by herself at a little round table in the back.  She had excellent posture and kept quite still--no fidgeting, no hair twisting, no smiling--while she watched the glittery and fabulous customers come and go.  Because her glasses were so large and so black, you could not tell whom she was looking at, which made the glittery, fabulous customers at the Pish Posh restaurant very, very nervous.

Eleven-year-old Clara Frankofile makes the glittery, fabulous customers nervous because she is able to spot, unerringly, people who have gone from being Somebodies to being Nobodies.  And Nobodies are not welcome at Pish Posh.

When she identifies Dr. Piff as a Nobody, his reaction leaves her feeling... unsettled.  Rather than slinking away, never to be seen (at least by Anybody Who Is Somebody) again, Dr. Piff sits down at Clara's private table.  And, before he leaves the restaurant forever, he mentions that there is something "peculiar and mysterious" going on at Pish Posh.  Something that Clara doesn't know about.  Which should be impossible.

But, as she soon discovers, it isn't.  There is something distinctly odd about Pish Posh's soup cook, but the investigation hits a dead end.  That forces her to do something she's never done before:  work with someone else.  And that someone else just so happens to be her own age -- and a jewel thief, to boot. 

I know I've said this before, but I really don't understand how or why Ellen Potter isn't more well-known.  Her books -- and I've now read all of them (so far) -- have a timeless quality that I'd think would appeal to Dahl and Snicket fans, as well as readers of older classics like Ruth Sawyer's Roller Skates.  Her books are set in the real world, but they have a fairy tale feel.

Pish Posh was no exception -- Clara, especially at first, is a bit of a horror:  pompous and snobby, an aged socialite in a young body.  But the more I learned about her, the more her behavior made sense, and, it wasn't long before her existence -- opulent private apartment, indoor roller coaster and all -- just seemed sad.

The mystery component of the story, while interesting and complicated (especially given the just-over-150-pages-length of the book), was very definitely secondary to Clara's personal journey.  This is a book about a girl figuring out what Life Is About.  And what she wants her life to be about.  Some readers have expressed distaste about the dark, violent part of the Pish Posh mystery, but that storyline, I felt, worked in favor of the classic feel -- think back to Roller Skates, for example (if you haven't read it, read it) -- and some have complained that there's too much going on in such a short book to allow for much depth, but the whole thing really worked for me.  I felt for Clara.  And I couldn't help liking her and rooting for her, even when she was being awful.

_________________________________________________________________

Previously:

Slob
Under the Radar Recommendation:  The Olivia Kidney books
2. Olivia Kidney and the Exit Academy
3. Olivia Kidney and the Secret Beneath the City

Comments

[tulip]

I loved this book! I read it when you recommended the Olivia Kidney books. I hadn't pinpointed what it was that I loved about the feel of her books but "Dahl-esque" is perfect. :)

[Christina]

This is such a great opening sentence. I'm hooked already. ::::Adding to tbr list:::

[cc]

Okay, I've been meaning to check her out since you reviewed Slob, but now I'm going to really do something about it. I've looked in BOTH my branch libraries and they don't have a single Ellen Potter book on the shelf. (Which is what reserves are all about of course, but...)

[Leila]

You have GOT to read Olivia Kidney. Seriously. Just order it. If you don't like it, I'll pay you back.

[Jennifer, Snapshot & (5MinutesforBooks)]

This sounds SO great. I haven't heard of Ellen Potter, but I love classic-y feeling books.

I might try one as a read aloud with my 10 1/2 year old daughter (who is WAY ahead of me in books)

[Leila]

She's great -- for real, give Olivia Kidney a try! I must spread the Ellen Potter gospel.

[amber]

I loved the book Pish Posh! You've got to read it!

[lauren]

what is the mystery in this book

[blank]

i am reading this book it is so great and mysterious goin off to read it buh bye.

[blank blank]

I LOVE this book. im in the middle of reading it but so far so good.... every one should read it.. i absolutly love it..

[sumra]

i love this book its really very intresting.Everyone should read that.

[Ceska]

This book bought joy to my kids, this is their all time favorite book. I’m glad they liked it, they’ve never been to book reading, not till now. Nice blog by the way.