« I need to read more Australian YA. | Main | Lookalikes. »

30 March 2010

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Anastasia

I have been wanting to read this book ever since I saw the cover a few weeks ago, which, misplace cat or no, is pretty nifty. I'm glad that you liked it, because I had the feeling that this is one of those books that could go either way-- but since you DO like it, I'll probably like it, too! :D

Kelly Fineman

My 15-yo LOVED this one. Didn't mention the cat incongruity, but was thrilled with the cover, which stands out on the bookstore shelves - they continue to be awash in black, blue and purple (evidently, the colors that say "supernatural"?) This one looked so much happier than most that she grabbed for it right away. Not one to judge a book only by its cover, she read flap copy and the first two pages or so at the store before we bought it. (I'm proud that my "training" is paying off - it saves us buying boos that she won't actually read.)

She liked it so much, in fact, that she chattered happily about it for about 20 minutes once she was done (completely spoiling the book for me in the process, but I don't mind - I love it when M gets so excited that she wants to babble about a book).

Angie

*grin* Now this is the review that has made me want to read this one. I was just waiting for one to pop up and you went and provided it for me. Thanks, Leila. Sounds like a blast.

Jen Hubert Swan

I. Love. This. Review. That is all:)

Leila

Kelly: Yes! So nice to read a less tortured fantasy. And it's awesome that she loved it enough to babble -- always a good sign!

Everyone else: Thank you and YAY! Have fun with it!

Apaperbackwriter.blogspot.com

Generally I tend to agree with your reviews, but I couldn't get past a few chapters of this book, as I felt the protagonist acted in ways inconsistent with her objectives -- which is a fancy way of saying that she didn't ring true with me at all. Perhaps it's because I'd just finished Once a Witch, which is not perfect but has significantly more believable characters, in my opinion.
Still, keep up those reviews; they help me a lot. :)

dotdotdot

This seemed like a great one to foist off on younger readers who want to be part of the paranormal fiction readership but who aren't quite ready for the grittier stuff. It was a definitely fun read.

Lisa

I read this one after reading your review, and it IS a lot of fun! I read the first chapter while waiting for my annual eye exam, and the other patients thought it was pretty funny that I snorted through my nose with laughter at that line "It's okay, baby! I don't need eyes to see you! I see you with the eyes of my heart, Felicia! My HEART!" After a recent surfeit of Twilight and even more badly written Twilight wannabes that I am having trouble justifying to myself how the hell I got involved in that anyway, Hex Hall was a nice palate refresher.

Gina @ My Precious

The cat on the front cover and her being allergic to them is a symbolism of sorts, or more or less an oxymoron. If you've read the book you know what I'm speaking of, if not I don't want to spoil anything.

Leila

Huh. You think?

The comments to this entry are closed.

GA

Blog powered by Typepad