Plain Kate -- Erin Bow

Judging entirely from the cover art, I picked up Plain Kate expecting a charming light British fantasy. That's what the cover suggested to me -- the girl on the cover looks like someone who is having a gently meandering adventure, the sort one could have on the way home from school, even. I expected to enjoy it, but I had no hint that there'd be anything memorable about it.

And that, my dears, is why I need to stop attempting to make predictions about books based solely on their covers. (It sounds obvious and simple, but it really is difficult NOT to do it.)

I wasn't expecting this story to Stand Out as something very different from most anything I've read in quite some time: I was wrong.

I wasn't expecting to be so enchanted by the storyline, world and characters that I'd be late to work because of it: I was wrong.

I wasn't expecting to find the plotting and characterization so constantly surprising that I'd be wondering How Things Would Work Out right up until the last page: I was wrong.

I wasn't expecting to get so emotionally invested in the characters that I'd burst into tears while recounting the plot to a co-worker an entire day later: I was wrong.

For that matter, I wasn't expecting, while writing about Plain Kate weeks after first reading it, to have my eyes well up all over again: I was wrong.

Even the first line:

A long time ago, in a market town by a looping river, there lived an orphan girl called Plain Kate.

didn't suggest any of the above to me -- instead, it suggested that Plain Kate would be a comfortable sort of olde fashionedy story about an orphan finding her place in the world: In that, too, I was wrong.

Erin Bow has achieved the timeless feel of a classic, but it isn't a comfortable, snuggly sort of story. The dangers faced are too dark, the sacrifices too great and the betrayals too huge for this to be a comfortable sort of story, and its told in such a way that you can see, through Kate and Taggle, what is truly right or wrong in each given situation, but you can also see -- and understand -- the motivations behind the choices the characters actually make.

I don't want to say much more about it, because, like the best books, it's a journey best left to the author and the characters, but the setting has an Eastern European feel, and the book features the best crotchety/selfish sidekick character since Calcifer. I'm sure you realize that I would not say that lightly.

Highly, seriously recommended to readers looking for A Good Book.

_________________________________________________

Book source: Review copy from the publisher.

Comments

[Kelia]

SO getting this out! This is the second good review I've read of it, so I'll definitely have to read it.

[R. J. Anderson]

I know. I KNOW. It's just... wonderful.

[notemily]

Adding this to my to-read list for sure. I saw it at the bookstore and was intrigued, but I hadn't read any reviews of it, so thanks for the post!

[Leila]

So, so, so good -- you know that when I get all inarticulate, I must love it!

[Beth]

Calcifer? CALCIFER?? Adding this to my to-read list right now.

[Leila]

Very, very different, but I think you'll see what I mean.

[tanita]

CALCIFER!? You have invoked The Name???
I am so excited - Sheila had good things to say about this one, too. Looking forward to it!!!!

[Jenn]

Off to ILL this bad boy right now (cause I know my library won't have it).

[Chachic]

Oh my, such a good review! I really can't wait to read this. I've heard so many good things about Plain Kate.

[Joyce]

I could swear one of my librarians reads your blog now. In the past 6 months or so there have been many books you reviewed that I NEED to read. I look it up at our library to find it's just been ordered. And really, the YA section is small, so it just can't be a coincidence.

[Claire]

Added to my to read list!